In a spontaneous comment on The Brink of Madness - A familiar place, an article by Victor Davis Hanson for the National Review, I laid out the simple case for ending popular support for violence, anywhere, anytime. The article had condemned liberals for not supporting Israel's response to the recent Hezbollah attacks.
Since I was led to the article by Digg.com, I placed my comment on Digg. Republished here.
"This is a point of view with some historical insight and a big historical blindness. Important to consider the truths stated, but also important to consider the unstated.- the historical truth that Israel's creation is a modern European crusade. This Euro-American Zionist invasion of Arab land, pushing out and killing rightful residents has created an entity that the world cannot afford to accept as a rightful state. Terrorist attacks on anyone by anyone cannot be supported. As we can understand anger, recognize wrong, we cannot condone violent attack by Hezbollah, Israel, US or insurgents anywhere. Differences need to be resolved in courts, violence must be recognized as sociopathic, a threat to all life."
Later today, I was led by Digg to an article asking Why America gives Israel its unconditional support? which prompted me to expound further in a Digg comment.
Republished here.
"It has never been more clear to me that the world, all of us cannot condone or tolerate violent actions, by governments, terrorist group, national liberation movements, insurgents of any type for any reason. Fundamentalists or revolutionaries, religious zealots, patriots or fascists are dangerous to the extent that they use violence or advocate the use of violence. Violent people are sociopathic -- a danger to all life. Leaders who extort, condone, or aid others in violent actions mislead and are harming us all. We can look back at the history of endless violent attack and violent retribution and see that this method of resolving conflicts is useless. All who wage or support war are corrupted by it and are condemned to lives of fear and guilt. It is contrary to the individual and collective's best interest to commit violent action in retribution for violence. What is in our best interest is to arrest, try and imprison perpetrators of violent acts. Our collective interest is best served by effective, fair and forceful containment of sociopaths. We need to use our collective creativity to discover successful police techniques to locate, disarm and imprison those found guilty of committing or causing the commission of violent acts. Killing or injuring anyone, whether by intent or by neglect is always a crime in every situation. We can no longer afford this love affair we have had with war and violence. The world is too small, there are too many of us, any hurt hurts us all. The proper response to a violent act is to isolate and surround the individuals responsible, humanely removing them from society. For the protection of all life and the quality of our own, we must make every effort to disarm and capture those individuals responsible for the violent act and to dismantle the economic, political, industrial system which sustained those actions. There are no right sides or wrong sides to any of the religious, political or historical conflicts plaguing life. There is only those who live and those who kill. We all need to unite to isolate violence. We are all in this life together, all life is precious, we must unite against any and all calls to violent actions or policies."
Looking on Flickr for an illustrative picture, the one above caught my eye. I think it expresses better than limb-less babies or bloody rubble the consequence of war. This picture shows the effects of fear on everyone, not only on those who get crushed or ripped apart by explosions or those who pull the triggers, but the way all of our lives are made into hell on earth.
The photo belongs to a group, named Mundo Uno - One World, One Future, for the Children.
Please, we all need to act now, act smart, act with care, with love to literally save the world. History does matter, grievances must be adjudicated. We all need justice. But there can be no justification for violent attack. We must make war a crime.



Recent Comments